Overcome a Narrow Focus on Fringe Groups and Beliefs by Using Spectrum Thinking for Deep Cultural and Structural Change

This post is a reproduction of a section from our white paper, Countering Male Supremacist Ideology and Violence: Challenges and Recommendations (PDF).

Barrier: Narrow Focus on Fringe Groups and Beliefs

Preventing and countering violent extremism programming emphasizes “fringe” or “radical” ideologies and/or participation in known supremacist extremist groups. The tendency to relegate supremacism (whether male supremacist, white supremacist, etc.) to the fringe beliefs of a small minority of the population situates it as a problem “over there” rather than one fundamental to society. This leads to the prioritization of resources to shift the beliefs of individual “at-risk” cisgender men and boys, or deradicalize those already active in overt supremacist groups, rather than addressing the elements of mainstream culture and institutions that contribute to the development of dehumanizing and entitled beliefs.

The focus on extremism and another popular term, polarization, contributes to a tendency toward a false equivalency between ideologies deemed radical on the left or the right. False equivalency, or claims of harm “on both sides,” is intentionally deployed by supremacists as a tactic to obscure the threat their ideologies pose. Political moderates and anti-extremism advocates can inadvertently help them by not challenging the premise that radical supremacist beliefs and radical social justice beliefs pose equivalent harm. Furthermore, a focus on countering extremism or radicalization implies that the center or the status quo is the ideological goal.

The fringe emphasis has directed attention away from the appearance of misogyny in mainstream culture and elevated individual care fields, such as mental health care, as solutions without considering their potential for complicity in harm. Therapists and counselors without training in identifying supremacist ideology may reinforce misogynist clients’ beliefs by buying into their narratives of themselves as victims. Organizations against domestic violence, for instance, warn that couples counselors may not recognize the signs of abuse, believing an abuser’s victimization narrative and inadvertently becoming complicit in the emotional abuse and gaslighting of the abused partner. The prevalence of racism, ableism, and transphobia among mental health care providers demonstrates the influence of mainstream cultural supremacism in many forms.

Recommendation: Use Spectrum Thinking for Deep Cultural and Structural Change

“Supremacism studies” is an alternative approach rooted in intersectionality that approaches supremacism as a spectrum. Replacing “radical” or “extremist” with the words they euphemize—i.e., “supremacist,” “authoritarian”—can redirect attention to the actual ideology that is harmful and undermine attempts to use false equivalency against anti-supremacist organizing. Under this approach, the terms “radical” and “extreme” are treated as modifying adjectives (ie, “extreme supremacist ideology) rather than stand-alone nouns. Removing the negative connotation from “radical” brings back the true meaning of radical liberation and social justice: addressing the structural roots of inequality rather than surface-level solutions.

Moving away from the terminology of extremism brings research on supremacism and authoritarianism into alignment with fields that understand supremacism as structuring society and value concepts such as radical liberation. Supremacism studies builds on fields such as race and ethnicity, feminist, queer, disability, and intersectionality studies that have long histories of recognizing and addressing supremacism as a core structuring force in mainstream society. It does not conflate violence with fringe activity, given that the prevalence of gender-based violence and rates of perpetration among cisgender men goes beyond a small fringe of actors.

Sexism, racism, homophobia, transphobia, xenophobia, and ableism are woven into the fabric of mainstream culture and institutions. It is crucial to design services that recognize male supremacist ideology and abusive behavior in a way that does not enact further harm or reinforce misogynists’ sense of victimization. Serving this need requires a deep investment in antioppressive approaches and understanding of structural harm involving multiple intersecting forms of supremacism. Meaningful transformation requires redirecting resources to a primary prevention approach that reaches the general population–especially children–to accomplish deep cultural change before individuals reach the point of absorbing extreme supremacist beliefs. Beliefs develop through narrative and emotional resonance, whether rooted in truth or misinformation. As such, education and entertainment offer primary sites for social change. Curricula founded in valuing empathy, consent, and critical thinking and oriented toward the entire youth population from an early age, not just those deemed at-risk, can provide a channel for effectively challenging the sticky cultural narratives underpinning male supremacist ideology and violence. Supremacists have actively targeted mainstream education and entertainment–from campaigns to censor books and movies, to training programs on taking over local school boards, to shaping textbook content–to prevent their potential for underpinning transformative change.

Anti-supremacist work includes valuing the human needs of communities working toward change while living within structural supremacism. Creative community-building initiatives— from queer dance parties and banana suits to disrupt Proud Boys protests to inflatable frog suits as part of the mass resistance against Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) violence and injustice—simultaneously challenge the fascist aesthetic and sustain participants by deploying humor and joy. Especially in times of heightened authoritarianism and trauma, access to beneficial individual and community care services and support is vital.


For the full list of references and sources informing this article, please consult the original white paper, ‘Countering Male Supremacist Ideology and Violence: Challenges and Recommendations’.

Next
Next

Recognize Misogyny by Deepening Expertise around Male Supremacist Ideology and Violence